Baby-Proofing: Is It Doing More Harm Than Good?

Baby-proofing. It’s every parent’s nightmare. What do I need to baby-proof? What is going to harm my child? What do I do when I go out? These questions can plague a parents sleep deprived mind well into the early hours of the morning. But in all honesty, do we need to baby-proof everything?

There is definitely a lot to be said for not baby-proofing; I personally have not gone out of my way to baby-proof. My main reason is this: when we visit other peoples’ houses, they are not baby-proofed, so I feel that I need my daughters to be prepared for this eventuality as the safeguards will not always be there.

A good example of this is when we visit one of my relatives house. It has always been full to the brim with nic-nacs, ornaments and general tat (it’s like an antique shop without the antiques) and I would perceive this to be a minefield of potential hazards to my children. When we go there, my relative runs around after my daughter continuously shouting “no”. It drives me insane, just move all your rubbish out of her reach if you don’t want her to touch it! But on the other hand, why should she have to? It is probably better for her to run around shouting then have to move everything every time we visit.

Similarly when we finally venture out of the home at the weekend, the places we visit are unlikely to be proofed. You would be hard pushed to find a restaurant that covers all its plug sockets and puts bumpers on the corners of their tables. It’s just not feasible. So how can we ensure our children are safe when we take them out of the confines of our bubble wrapped homes? I always find a proactive approach towards safety is paramount.

Some people may think I am a few sandwiches short of a picnic by not having locks on my cupboard doors and plug covers on my plug sockets (not that there are any of these in my house that aren’t in use), but I believe that it is an important learning tool and one that will ultimately help my children when they do leave the house on outings.

From my experience, it is pure curiosity coupled with prohibition that makes children enter into a situation that can be considered to be dangerous. Bearing that in mind, we took the decision to experiment by clearing out a low level cupboard and filling it with all my Tupperware tubs, mixing bowls (all plastic now) and various paper plates and plastic cups. Emily was thrilled and spent the next hour playing with its contents whilst I cooked dinner. From then on she made a beeline for this cupboard over any other and has never even attempted to go into our forbidden under-the-sink cupboard.

Now don’t get me wrong, when it comes to baby-proofing I definitely do my ground work first; I am meticulous at tidying up after myself, making sure all potential hazards like laptop chargers and sharp objects and hazardous chemicals are well out of reach. I can not stress enough the need to tidy away anything that can cause injuries. This is probably the best form of potential baby-proofing that any good parent can undertake … and it is by far the cheapest.

The only other form of absolute baby-proofing that cannot be avoided is the stair gate. There is no way around it. There is only so much curiosity you can fend off without putting a definitive barrier in your child’s way.

But despite all of the above, I am still a firm believer that every child is different and that at the end of the day, mother definitely knows best. However, it is vital that we make sure we do not go over the top when it comes to proofing as our children will not be aware of hazards when they leave the home.

So before you go out and buy as many plug covers as you have plug sockets and spend a fortune of door locks, consider whether its really necessary for your child.


10 responses to “Baby-Proofing: Is It Doing More Harm Than Good?

  1. Loving this!, we are of the same mind, my little boy (18 months). We have been very meticulous about what is in arms reach and again we have not used every gadget going into order to ‘babyproof’. As my son is never left without one of use we dont see the need for going OTT (having said that we have one catch on the sink cupboard). We also dont have stair gates at the moment as he is never left near the stairs nor can he access them on his own. When he moves into his big boy room (normal bed) we will consider putting one on his bedroom door just to ensure no midnight trips in the night! My hubby and i both suffer with pelvic/hip conditions and stair gates would really cause more aggro than we suffer already getting up and down stairs, but since he doesn’t have the opportunity to access them we are not going to invest in them and lets be honest there are non at any grandparents house so teaching him from the beginning what he can and cant do is always benificial!

    • Oh wow Jaime, what bad luck you both having back problems. That sounds dreadful. Who does all the heavy lifting? We only have one baby gate on out eldest’s bedroom door. It was originally downstairs from the living room to the hall, but everyone and i mean EVERYONE fell over it when they came over, so it was actually more dangerous than not. I definitely think less is more.

      • Hubbys hips are shot and will need hip replacements before he is 40 and and min is (SPD) pregnancy related and most peoples gets better although mine hasnt (18 months on) so normally i do the bulk of heavy stuff as it makes no difference as i am in pain everyday 😦 .

        I really really enjoyed reading your post and i am certainly with you on the less is more! 🙂

  2. Wow I remember baby proofing xxx my main worry was the plug sockets, my youngest used to post spoons and all sorts into the video recorder xxx

  3. Anyone who knows anything about electrics in the UK should know that there is absolutely no reason to have plug socket plugs. The earth pin is longer than the live and neutral for this very reason. There is no power until the earth pin is fully engaged. Therefore, unless you child is cleaver enough to push a screwdriver all the way in to the earth pin hole, hold in there, and then insert another screwdriver into the live pin hole there is no risk at all. If the above does sound like something your child would do then consider the harm they could potentially inflict with 2 screwdrivers?! They could certainly removed a plastic socket cap!! The companies that sell these are praying on the ignorance of the general public and the scare mongering that seems to be wide spread in the parent community.

    • Just read this back and spotted all the spelling errors. Predictive text! Cleaver instead of clever is my favourite!

    • Wow Peter, thanks for the comment. I had no idea about the earth pin being different. That makes me even more irritated by the companies selling plug covers. And lol … cleaver was definitely my favourite too!

  4. I have a good friend who baby-proofed NOTHING and it worked out fine! We did baby proof, but our son was a climber (boy was he) so it was necessary for his safety. 🙂 Happy to be visiting you from the weekend hop!

    • Thanks for visiting Rosey! Yes, Emily is a bit of a climber, but she’s more of an explorer, so its easier to distract her with shiny things. I’m glad your friend had no problems with when they didn’t babyproof. I do think it is a bit of a gimmick.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s